This is one of the most common practical questions that comes up when a founder is ready to invest seriously in their brand.

The business has grown. The current website no longer reflects it. Something needs to change. And before any of the strategic or design work begins, there is a platform decision to make.

The answer, like most things in brand strategy, depends on what the business actually needs, not what the platform is capable of in general, but what your specific offer, audience, and growth trajectory require from a website.

Here is how I think about it.

What Squarespace does well

Squarespace is the platform I use most often for service-based businesses, and for good reason. It is clean, well-structured, and produces websites that look considered without requiring a developer on retainer to keep them running.

For founders whose primary offer is a service - consultancy, coaching, strategy, creative work - Squarespace handles everything the website needs to do: a strong homepage that earns the enquiry, a clear services architecture, a blog, a booking or contact mechanism, and the SEO foundations that make the site findable over time.

It is also genuinely manageable. Once the site is built and handed over, a founder can update copy, add blog posts, and make straightforward changes without needing to go back to a designer every time something needs to shift. For a scaling business where messaging evolves quickly, that matters.

What it is not is infinitely flexible. If you need highly specific functionality - complex membership structures, intricate course delivery, large-scale e-commerce - Squarespace will take you some of the way but not all of it.

When Kajabi makes more sense

If a significant part of your offer involves digital products: online courses, membership communities, gated content, structured programmes with their own learning experience, Kajabi is worth serious consideration.

Kajabi is built specifically for this. It handles course delivery, community functionality, email marketing, and sales pages within a single ecosystem. For a founder whose business model depends on digital product revenue, having all of that integrated rather than stitched together across multiple platforms has real operational advantages.

The trade-off is design flexibility. Kajabi sites tend to look like Kajabi sites. If visual distinctiveness and brand authority are priorities, and for the founders I work with, they usually are, this requires more deliberate creative direction to overcome.

The decision I most often help clients work through is whether the operational simplicity of having everything in one place outweighs the design constraints. For businesses where the digital product is the primary offer, it usually does.

When Shopify enters the conversation

If you are selling physical products at any meaningful scale, Shopify is the most capable platform available. The e-commerce infrastructure is more sophisticated than either Squarespace or Kajabi, the inventory management is robust, and the ecosystem of integrations is extensive.

For service businesses with a product arm, a founder who also sells physical goods alongside a consultancy or coaching offer — the more honest conversation is often whether those two things belong on the same site at all, or whether they are better served by separate presences with a clear relationship between them.

Shopify for the product. Squarespace for the service and brand. That separation, done well, allows each to do its job without compromise.

Fussy Food Plates Multi Device Mockup.png

The question that comes before the platform decision

Here is where I want to be direct, because this is where the decision most often goes wrong. The platform question feels urgent when a rebrand or website project begins. It should not be the first question answered.

Before you decide where to build, you need to know what the site needs to do — specifically, commercially, in terms of the journey a potential client takes from first encounter to enquiry. That is a strategy question, not a technology question. And the answer to it will make the platform decision straightforward.

A website built on the right platform but without a documented content strategy, a clear messaging hierarchy, and a positioning argument that holds will not perform regardless of how well it is designed. A website built on a considered strategic foundation will perform on any of the platforms above, provided the platform is matched correctly to the offer.

This is why the work I do always starts with strategy. The Brand Clarity Session is where that thinking happens — before a platform is chosen, before a visual direction is set, before a single page is built. It produces a written strategic summary that answers the questions the website then needs to express.

The platform comes after that. The design comes after that. In that sequence, the technology decision becomes the straightforward practical choice it should always have been.

Not sure where your current site stands?

The Brand Authority Score is a free three-minute assessment that shows you clearly where your website and brand are working and where they are losing ground. It is a useful starting point before any platform or redesign conversation begins.